polly
7th Year
Registration date: 2006-03-12
Number of posts: 10719
Age: 17
Location: England
Real First Name: Polly
Country: 
House: Ravenclaw!
Crest: 
Warning:
Award Bar:
Contribution Points: 1559
RPG Forum : Great Hall
RPG Character Name: Polly Swindail
Race: Witch
Good or Evil: Dumbledores Army
 |  Subject: Tarot debate  Sun 30 Nov - 22:49 | |
| Tarot debate
Hey guys were gonna do something a little different this time and focus on tarot readings. Elfie posted an assignment on them once before. http://hogwarts-experience.heavenforum.com/completed-ancient-rune-classes-f65/runes-v-tarot-t2145.htm
But this time I want you to debate.
Simple question do you think that tarot reading is really a form of rune reading?
There’s a possible of 50 house points available depending on the participation. With an extra 10 house points for the best debater.
Have fun!
_________________  |
|
Sashi
Ravenclaw Prefect
Registration date: 2008-09-27
Number of posts: 8273
Age: 18
Location: Crying under my pile of marshmallows. Guess I am not that depressed at all since I am munching on some from time to time.
Real First Name: Sashi, my friends shortens it to Sash, Bunny calls me Sasha..and James calls me Xixin..wee!! ^^,
Country: 
House: house where WIT BEYOND MEASURE IS MAN'S GREATEST TREASURE!! ^^,
Crest:
Warning:
Award Bar:
Contribution Points: 2437
RPG Forum : Great Hall
RPG Character Name: Lolly Fang, Courtney de Grieu, Charm Prince
Race: Witch
Good or Evil: Dumbledores Army
| | Subject: Re: Tarot debate Thu 4 Dec - 9:47 | |
| To start the debate
Standing for: Tarot reading is not a form of rune reading.
Tarot reading is NOT a form of rune reading. One big fact that'll support that would be their difference in terms of casting. Divination of rune is not fortunetelling, it is said to be | Quote: | | for analyzing the path that one is on and the likely outcome |
, where as for tarot reading, it is and has been used for fortunetelling. Sources;
Wikipedia
Tarotpedia_________________ Carreio is my awesome GUARDiAN ANGEL! |
|
drkangelcat
Second Head of Slytherin
Registration date: 2007-02-02
Number of posts: 4303
Location: In la la land.
Real First Name: Angelique [call me Cat]
Country: 
House: Slytherin's Official Nut
Crest: 
Warning:
Award Bar:
Contribution Points: 1105
RPG Forum : Great Hall
RPG Character Name: Catherine Van Buiren / Charmaine Bletchley
Race: Vampire
Good or Evil: Deatheater
| | Subject: Re: Tarot debate Wed 4 Feb - 20:54 | |
| I do agree that it is not a type of rune reading since it does not usually contain runes on it, but I do not agree with Sashi's explanation of the difference. | Quote: | | for analyzing the path one is on and the likely outcome |
Both do that. Fortunetelling, though an extremely archaic term and looked down up by many psychics, is basically just like the quote above. It will not tell the future, but a possible outcome based on your path. And like with rune readings, it will give the psychic advice to tell you on how to get there or what you should change.
So then what would be a difference? Well ruin readings contain runes and tarot reading use cards. Sometimes readers will use a stone or rune to charge a deck, but even then I wouldn't call it a ruin reading since there are no runes being read.
Sources:
Personal experiences and knowledge passed down from parents. |
|
polly
7th Year
Registration date: 2006-03-12
Number of posts: 10719
Age: 17
Location: England
Real First Name: Polly
Country:
House: Ravenclaw!
Crest:
Warning:
Award Bar:
Contribution Points: 1559
RPG Forum : Great Hall
RPG Character Name: Polly Swindail
Race: Witch
Good or Evil: Dumbledores Army
| |
